Updated: November 2026

Estimated read time: 6 minutes

Quick Answer: Yes, it is a valid and fairly common decision to stay at APS6 after acting at EL1. Good reasons include a poor fit with the business area, a personal life that needs more space right now, or holding out for a better EL1 opportunity. Your acting experience stays on your record and can be used as evidence in future EL1 applications.

Chose Not to Go Permanent EL1? What Reddit Says About Staying at APS6

Contents

A question keeps surfacing in APS communities online: if you had the chance to go permanent EL1, would you take it? Increasingly, the answer is not always yes.

The Reddit Question Many APS Employees Are Asking

A thread on the r/AusPublicService subreddit on Reddit raised a question many APS employees quietly share. The poster pointed out that most career conversations focus on climbing the ladder and chasing the next promotion, and asked to hear from people who had the chance to go higher but chose to stay at APS6.

The poster was in that situation themselves. After several months acting at EL1, with good performance reviews, a pay increase and a stronger resume, they decided not to pursue the permanent role. The business area did not feel like the right long term fit at either level, and they wanted to focus on their personal life. What they really wanted was reassurance that the decision was valid and that they were not letting a permanent EL1 slip away for no good reason.

If you have searched Google for something like “APS6 or EL1 Reddit” or “should I take permanent EL1”, you are almost certainly asking the same thing. This post is our take, drawn from years of public sector recruitment and panel experience.

Why People Walk Away From Permanent EL1

There is an assumption baked into most career advice: progression is always the goal, and saying no to a promotion signals a lack of ambition. In the APS, where EL1 is often seen as the step from doing the work to leading it, that assumption runs deep. But the reasons for declining are usually thoughtful, and they tend to fall into a few themes.

The role or area is not the right fit

Acting opportunities do not always land in places that match your long term interests. You can perform well, meet the standard and earn strong feedback, while knowing the work, the team or the business area is not where you want to build a career. Locking in a permanent role in the wrong place just to hold the classification is a trade-off many people decide against.

Your personal life is a legitimate priority

EL1 brings more complex work, greater accountability, people management expectations and, often, longer hours. If you are in a season with young children, caring responsibilities, study, health considerations or simply a need for more space, that trade-off may not make sense right now. Protecting your time is a considered career decision, not a retreat.

The timing is wrong

A permanent EL1 in the wrong agency or branch can narrow your options as easily as it widens them. At certain career stages, mobility is worth more than locking in at the next level. Staying at APS6 can keep you free to move laterally, explore other policy or program areas and apply across the APS.

You would rather find the right EL1 than take the available one

There is a big difference between a permanent EL1 you feel lukewarm about and one you are genuinely excited by. Holding out for the second is not timidity. It is strategy.

What You Keep From Acting at EL1

The experience does not disappear because you decline the permanent role. The months you spent acting at EL1, the complexity you navigated, the leadership you showed and the outcomes you delivered all remain part of your track record.

When you later apply for an EL1 role that genuinely fits, you will not be starting from scratch. You will be applying with evidence of performance at level, which is one of the strongest things a candidate can bring to an APS selection process. Panels assess against the Work Level Standards, and real examples from EL1 work show you can operate at that level.

Declining now is not the same as deciding never to go EL1. It is choosing to be intentional about where and when you make the move.

The Question Worth Asking Yourself

One question cuts through much of the noise: Am I saying no because I am genuinely not ready, or because this particular opportunity is not right for me?

The first answer may be worth examining, because sometimes hesitation is a useful signal and sometimes it is fear of change dressed up as self-awareness. The second answer is simply good judgement. Knowing which one applies to you is where honest reflection, and often a conversation with someone outside the situation, helps most.

When You Are Ready, Make It Count

Whether you take the permanent EL1 now, wait for a better fit or pivot to a different area of the APS, preparation matters most at the moment you decide to move. EL1 recruitment is competitive. Panels look for leadership, sound judgement, the ability to manage complexity and a clear sense of the value you add at level.

Your acting experience is a real advantage, but only if you can articulate it well. That is where professional public sector interview coaching makes a tangible difference. We help you turn acting experience into structured, panel-ready evidence, and you can also work through our APS interview questions guide to see the behavioural prompts you are likely to face.

If you are weighing up your next step and want an honest second opinion, you can book a free 15-minute strategy call with our team.

FAQs About Declining a Permanent EL1

Is it okay to turn down a permanent EL1 after acting in the role?

Yes. Many APS employees decline a permanent EL1 because of fit, timing or personal circumstances. Good performance while acting does not oblige you to lock in a permanent role, and your experience stays on your record.

Will declining a permanent EL1 hurt my career?

Not usually. You keep the evidence from your acting period, and future EL1 opportunities will continue to be advertised. What matters is that when you do apply, you choose the right role and prepare well.

Can I use my acting EL1 experience in future applications?

Yes. Acting experience is valid evidence of performance at level. Use specific examples that show your individual contribution, judgement and results, and align them to the EL1 Work Level Standards.

Is APS6 or EL1 the better choice?

It depends on your priorities. EL1 offers higher pay and greater scope but also more accountability and, often, people leadership. APS6 can offer a better balance and more mobility. The right choice is the one that fits your current goals, workload tolerance and the specific role on offer.

How should I prepare when I do apply for a permanent EL1?

Prepare a strong written application, structure your examples using STAR or STAR-L, and practise answering behavioural questions at EL1 level. Professional coaching can help you present your acting experience clearly and confidently.

Your Decision Is Valid

If you have chosen not to pursue a permanent EL1 because the role, the area or the timing is not right, that is not a failure and it is not a missed opportunity you will always regret. It is a considered decision by someone who knows what they want. There will be more EL1 vacancies, more acting opportunities and more recruitment rounds. What matters is that when you decide to go for it, you go for the right one, and you go in prepared.

View our EL1 interview coaching packages and pricing.

About PS Interview Coach

PS Interview Coach provides APS, State Government and public sector interview coaching across Australia. Our coaching team brings more than 40 years of combined public sector recruitment, panel, application and interview experience. We help candidates prepare structured applications, selection criteria, pitch responses, STAR interview examples and level-appropriate APS capability evidence. Learn more about PS Interview Coach.